The Red Sox did both buy and sell, as was their best course of action at the trade deadline. The moves they made make you wonder if Chaim Bloom believes this team is capable of making a playoff push and if he should have done more to remake the club with 2023 and beyond in mind. Boston improved its outfield offense and improved all around at first base. Yet, they got worse defensively in the outfield and offensively at catcher. They are short a left-handed reliever in the bullpen, too. If Bloom believed in this team, he would have acquired a reliever or two to improve its weakest link. But, I digress. Among the, let’s say, interesting moves by Bloom is the Christian Vasquez trade.

Christian Vasquez Trade a Mostly Logical Move

Christian Vasquez was one of the Red Sox’s best players going into the deadline, so it was always possible he would be traded depending on which direction Chaim Bloom decided to go. Knowing this could happen doesn’t make it hurt any less and didn’t make for a happy clubhouse after Monday’s win. Alex Cora was emotional about it, too.

Bloom acknowledged the impact trading Vasquez would have on the clubhouse. But he said he has to do what’s best for the organization. Which, makes all the sense in the world in a vacuum. Vasquez is a pending free agent, and the Red Sox didn’t want to risk not getting compensation for him if he had left this offseason. Plus, Boston received catcher Reese McGuire, who’s under team control through 2025, in a separate trade with the White Sox for Jake Diekman. Trading a pending free agent and acquiring a controllable replacement is typically a good baseball move. However, McGuire is nowhere near the caliber of catcher that Vasquez is, so how is he an improvement to the 2022 team?

Chaim Bloom’s never really thought highly of Christian as a player, anyway. I mean, he’s tried to trade the Sox’ veteran catcher more than once since he was hired.

Red Sox Wouldn’t Blindside Vasquez About a Trade, Would They?

There was some confusion, too, over whether Vasquez knew about the trade before talking to reporters. It seemed like the trade caught him off guard based on this clip:

Thankfully, that wasn’t the case. Cora told him of the trade before he took batting practice. Vasquez requested to take BP with his Boston teammates one last time, and Cora obliged.

The trade going down about an hour before Monday’s game added even more to the drama.

Christian Vasquez hit .282/.327/.432/.759 with eight home runs, 42 RBI, and a 107 OPS+ in 84 games with the Red Sox this season. He was fifth on the Red Sox in hits (83), doubles (20), and RBI (42); he was third in batting average and fourth in on-base percentage, slugging percentage, OPS, OPS+, and bWAR (1.7).

Christian Vasquez Has Become an All-Around MLB Catcher

Pictured: Christian Vasquez, traded to the Houston Astros on August 2, 2022, celebrates reaching base in a game. He is wearing the Red Sox' home white jersey and pants with red batting gloves and a red arm sleeve on his left arm.

Christian was drafted by the Red sox in 2008 and made his MLB debut on July 9, 2014. A.J. Pierzynski (remember him?) was kicked to the curb a week later. Vasquez missed the 2015 season after undergoing Tommy John surgery that April, forcing Blake Swihart to the big leagues. From 2016 on, Vasquez has been among the game’s best defensive catchers. He hasn’t been the best framer the past couple of seasons, though; Kevin Plawecki has better framing stats this season, believe it or not. Vasquez has thrown out 35 percent of attempted base stealers in his career to date.

Splitting catching duties with Sandy Leon for years, something clicked for Christian, who’s always had a flare for the dramatic, in his first season as the everyday catcher in 2019. He hit .276/.320/.477/.798 with a 101 OPS+, 72 RBI and a still-to-this-date career-high 23 home runs over 138 games in 2019. The bat regressed in 2020-21 but came back again in 2022.

Christian Vasquez has become a solid everyday MLB catcher, making him a valuable trade piece that was worth a pair of solid prospects from the Houston Astros.

The Prospects

Pictured: Enmanual Valdez, acquired in the Christian Vasquez trade, is at-bat, wearing a light blue jersey top with a red number 2, and white jersey pants rolled up to his knees, exposing red socks. He is wearing a black helmet.

Boston is getting two prospects back in the Christian Vasquez trade. Enmanuel Valdez, 23, is a left-handed hitter who’s played mostly second base and third base. Valdez began the 2022 season in Double-A, where he dominated (1.112 OPS, 11 home runs, 45 RBI in 44 games). He was moved to Triple-A and dominated there as well (.907 OPS, 10 home runs, 32 RBI) in 38 games before the trade. Valdez was ranked by Baseball America as the Astros’ 12th best prospect. Signed out of the Dominican Republic in 2015, Valdez is a complete hitter who makes contact at an above-average rate, knows the strike zone, and hits the ball hard. But questions remain about his long-term position defensively, per his BA scouting report.

The Red Sox have assigned him to Triple-A Worcester, where he’s gotten off to a hot start.

Pictured from behind home plate: <a rel=

Wilyer Abreu, 23, is an outfielder who has spent the 2022 season at Double-A. He hit .249/.399/.459/.858 with 15 home runs and 54 RBI in 89 games at the level before the trade. Baseball America ranked him the Astro’s 21st best prospect. Signed out of Venezuela in 2017, Abreu is a flyball heavy hitter who hits for power (good in-game power ability) and gets on base (walks a lot). He has improved his bat-to-ball skills since 2020 and is a patient hitter with a good eye, but he can also strike out often because of his patient approach. Abreu is capable of being a centerfielder but can play all three outfield spots, according to his BA scouting report.

Trading Vasquez Made Most Sense in a Retooling Scenario

Pictured: Christian Vasquez, with a look of disbelief upon his face, swarmed by media a Minute Maid Park moments after the news of his trade to the Astros broke.

The Christian Vasquez trade made the most sense only in particular scenarios. Trading a player with expiring team control for prospects and replacing him with a player under team control for multiple seasons is a good baseball trade. This is what making a trade with the future in mind looks like. But, based on the transactions made at the deadline, the Red Sox are not in one of those scenarios where the Christian Vasquez trade made the most sense.

The Red Sox have a chance at the playoffs, don’t they, Chaim? If he truly believes that, why trade away one of your best hitters this season? Making a move like this suggested, at least to me, that Boston’s front office would go all-in on retooling for 2023. Instead, they made moves on the margins, upgrading offense in some areas at the expense of defense in other areas (it’d be fine if Jackie Bradley Jr. were still around) in hopes of making a run at a Wild Card spot in 2022.

Read Chaim Bloom’s full comments on Boston’s newest prospects and Christian Vasquez’s goodbye to Boston he posted on his Instagram after the trade.

For daily Red Sox coverage, follow me on Twitter. For more MLB coverage, follow @BellyUpBaseball and check out Belly Up Sport’s other MLB content.

About Author

Cody Bondeson

I've been a Red Sox fan for as long as I can remember, having lived in New England for nearly half of my life. But it wasn't until I was about 12 or 13 years old that I became obsessed with the Red Sox. Though I live and breathe Red Sox 24/7, I am a more reasoned fan (thus a more reasoned writer) than the stereotypical Red Sox fan and not prone to getting caught up in the ups and downs that come with a 162 game MLB season --- Even a great player fails more than he succeeds, after all.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.