Another tough week in Giants land, and episode 62 of the Third and Ten Podcast captures every moment of it. Hosted by Nathan Nguyen and Brian Germinaro, the show dives deep into the sobering reality of New York Giants football, the hope provided by Abdul Carter’s breakout, and the ongoing frustration of another one-score defeat—this time at the hands of the Commanders, 29-22.
Opening Observations: Familiar Pain, New Draft Hope
Nguyen starts the episode by welcoming listeners and setting the stage for the state of despair (and slight resignation). Germinaro relates a conversation with a Patriots fan who’s only just discovering the agony of regular-season disappointment, confirming that, “no, you never get used to it—it just gets worse.”
There’s numbness and acceptance in the air as both hosts talk about watching games without expectations. After all, the Giants will ultimately find a way to lose.
Giants vs. Commanders: Recap & Key Moments
The hosts quickly get into the meat of the episode: Giants-Commanders. Nguyen admits he fell asleep during the third quarter, having already seen enough to sense the inevitable outcome. Germinaro notes that while the Giants technically had chances to win, none were capitalized on. The pair laments yet another one-score loss—remarking that the Giants seem to be the photographic negative of teams like the Vikings or Broncos, who usually eke out those close victories.
Franchise Building: The Draft and Quarterback Situation
Both Nathan and Brian agree that the only thing this game impacted was draft position. For once, there’s relief in watching the highest pick come closer into view—whether that means selecting a talent or trading down for a haul of picks.
When the conversation shifts to the Giants’ quarterback, both are thankful for having their franchise guy. They are also adamant that the team does not need to chase another QB in this year’s weaker draft class. They push back against social media hot takes about moving on from Jaxson Dart, agreeing that he has shown flashes that justify building the supporting cast rather than starting over at the position.
Abdul Carter Arrives
The real bright spot? The dominant performance of Abdul Carter. Brian points out the parallels to Kayvon Thibodeaux’s rookie breakout. Nathan is fired up about Carter’s big stat line: 7 tackles, a sack, 2 forced fumbles, and a recovery. The hosts discuss how Carter is maturing, finally responding to coaching and finding his place as a disruptive force—just what the Giants need to spark long-term defensive success.
Problems Persist: Play Calling, Injuries, and Roster Holes
Despite Carter’s ascent, there’s plenty to criticize. The duo calls out the $36M man, Darius Slayton, for his recurring drops, and questions the logic in rewarding “locker room guys” over actual production. Jalen Hyatt has also been a disappointment, and Nguyen is particularly harsh on Dexter Lawrence’s checked-out performance this season.
Special teams mistakes, uninspired play calling from Mike Kafka, and ongoing coaching/GM failures lead to calls for sweeping changes at the top. Both hosts make it clear: this franchise is desperate for new energy, a new strategy, and a new front office.
Around the League: Quick Hits
The podcast rounds out with rapid-fire takes on other NFL headlines—Kyle Pitts finally having a big game, the Bengals potentially imploding post-Burrow depression, Kansas City’s dynasty taking a step back as Mahomes recovers, and the Bills being the most dangerous Wild Card team in the AFC.
Mets Offseason Moves
Brian offers his take on the Mets’ signing of Jorge Polanco. Ultimately, it’s seen as a solid, versatile move for New York, although it’s most likely a sign that Jeff McNeil’s time is coming to an end. Germinaro speculates about more moves coming, including a possible push for Cody Bellinger or others to add more punch to the lineup.
Final Thoughts: Waiting for the Turnaround
There’s some hope among the despair. Both hosts are ready for the offseason and all the possibilities that come with draft picks, mock drafts, and free agency. The patience required to be a Giants fan is wearing thin, but Nathan Nguyen and Brian Germinaro continue to endure—providing honest, insightful, and passionate analysis for every listener riding out this rough era.
Thank you for reading. Make sure to follow us on social media!
- Nate’s Twitter + Instagram
- Brian’s Twitter
- Podcast Twitter + Instagram
- All full episodes can be found on Belly Up’s YouTube channel
Make sure to check out bellyupsports.com for more sports content!
